STAFF NEWS & ANALYSIS
Amish Mount Final Fight Against School Vaccine Mandates: ‘Only the Supreme Court Can Save Them Now’
By Ben Bartee - October 30, 2026

Originally published via Armageddon Prose:

As fastidiously documented here at Armageddon Prose, Public Health™ authorities across multiple northeastern states have placed the “anti-vaxxer” Amish community firmly in their sights over the past several years, targeting them with relentless lawfare and other forms of pressure in an effort to coerce compliance.

The Amish have thus far refused — and valiantly so.

In Pennsylvania, as we covered last month, Chester County has dispatched a portly totalitarian nurse called Dale Weiser to Amish country, tasked with proverbial door-kicking — literally going door-to-door with syringe in hand — in order to try to coerce them into submitting to measles vaccination right there on the spot.

Related: New York Attorney General Letitia James Sues RFK Jr. Over Childhood Vaccine Schedule

In New York, a years-long legal fight over school vaccine mandates appears to be drawing closer to conclusion after several private Amish schools have racked up $118K in unpaid fines since 2022 for their refusal to mandate vaccines per state law, as amended in 2019 — incidentally, curiously, just in time for the COVID pandemic.

Related: WebMD Claims COVID Vax ‘Still Crucial for Children’

Via Reason:

“From 1966 to 2019, unvaccinated students were allowed to attend school in New York with a medical exemption issued by a physician, or if they “hold genuine and sincere religious beliefs” opposed to vaccination…

Officials amended the state’s legal code in June 2019 to remove all religious exemptions to school vaccine mandates. The legislator who introduced the bill, Jeffrey Dinowitz (D–Bronx), attributed the outbreak [of measles] to “misinformation and irresponsible rhetoric.” But instead of scaling up information campaigns, he chose to crack down on religious freedom.

In 2022, the government issued $118,000 in fines targeting three rural Amish schoolhouses—all of which are privately run, privately funded, and exclusively attended by members of the local Amish community—for failing to comply with the mandate.”

After working its way through the state and federal court system, three federal courts ruled consecutively against the Amish — first in the Western District of New York, then the Second Circuit Court of Appeals, then the Second Circuit Court of Appeals again after the Supreme Court asked it to reconsider its initial ruling.

—————————————–

[If you appreciate this breed of journalism free from advertiser or gatekeeper influence, please consider a $5/month or $50/year Substack subscription or a one-time digital “coffee” donation.]

——————————————

“Only the Supreme Court can save them now,” the plaintiffs’ lawyer, Hiram Sasser, said.

New York’s fruitcake of a governor, Kathy Hochul — who wears a necklace that spells out “vaxed” and once declared the COVID shot rollout was divine intervention from God — more recently declared a “state disaster emergency” over a whopping twelve cases of measles.

Related: Elizabeth Warren DESTROYED by X Community Notes Over Pharma Corruption

Via WKBW:

“The legal fight comes as measles cases increase across the country.

New York Gov. Kathy Hochul declared a state disaster emergency this month as cases continued to rise. Western New York has reported 12 confirmed cases so far this year, according to New York State’s measles dashboard, with additional cases in counties to the east. Pennsylvania is also dealing with a major outbreak.

[Legal analyst Michael] Macomber said the public health concerns could weigh in the state’s favor as the Supreme Court considers whether to hear the case.

“A lot of that pressure is going to come into play as well, and that it does weigh in favor of the arguments that this is really, in fact, a health concern,” he said.

New York health officials have previously pointed to the state’s elimination of religious exemptions as a factor in limiting the spread of measles.”

Related: MAHA-Sponsored Infant Hepatitis B Vaccine Trial Is Axed After WHO Sabotage

In an obvious bid to gin up maximum terror and galvanize public support for the tyranny her administration inflicts on the Amish and New Yorkers at large, Hochul’s administration is now keeping a COVID-style terror chart up on its website tracking measles cases in the same way that CNN put up alleged COVID deaths on its chyron 24/7 at the height of the pandemic.

Benjamin Bartee, author of Broken English Teacher: Notes From Exile (now available in paperback), is an independent Bangkok-based American journalist with opposable thumbs.

Follow AP on X.

Subscribe (for free) to Armageddon Prose and its dystopian sister, Armageddon Safari.

Support AP’s independent journalism with a one-off, hassle-free “digital coffee” tip or Patreon.

Bitcoin public address: bc1qvq4hgnx3eu09e0m2kk5uanxnm8ljfmpefwhawv



Posted in STAFF NEWS & ANALYSIS
loading